From time to time, I get letters from friends who apparently don’t read my blog… If they did, they probably wouldn’t be asking me some of these questions about their relationships. {snicker} I received this one the other day and thought I would post it…
Dear Melanie,
I’ve been dating this great guy for about four months and have been really enjoying his company. He gets along great with my pet cats and enjoys all the same things as I do. As you already know, after my last two relationships, I’m an incredibly mistrustful person. No matter how much I think this guy may like me, I’m still waiting for “that other shoe to drop”. In my obsessive search for something ‘wrong’, I ended up checking his email. You don’t have to tell me, I already know its wrong but I couldn’t help it… Now I wish I hadn’t.
It turns out that he still keeps in contact with his last girlfriend and the two of them have been exchanging emails. Some of them are just little updates but its the ones where she tells him that she misses talking to him that bother me the most. And from what I can tell, she doesn’t know about me at all.
To top it all off, over the past week or so, he has started deleting the emails. I think he’s hiding them. Why would he do this? And how do I confront him?
Sincerely,
Miss Trusting in Maryland
First off… Although I can completely empathize with you, I can’t condone your invasion into someone elses privacy. I can understand that after being lied to repeatedly in the past, you feel the need to cover your butt so you don’t feel like a fool later down the road… But at what point do you just accept a guy for face value and not question his intentions? I’m just throwing that out there because honestly I don’t know the answer to that either.
Now, on to your actual problem… Firstly, I’ll confess that I still keep in contact with B frequently… by frequently, I mean sometimes it’s daily… sometimes it’s weekly… I truly believe it’s only natural since B is one of my closest friends and has been for over two years… We have a lot in common when it comes to kids, music, TV shows, books, you name it… However, I don’t hide my conversations with him… In fact, it’s common knowledge around the household that I still frequently converse with him… Hence my first point… Your guy is hiding it and that is the Numero Uno reason to be suspicious… What does he have to hide? Is it the fact that he still converses with her and he doesn’t want you to be hurt? But what could possibly hurt you within a simple conversation? Yeah… I’m skeptical concerning the hidden nature of the conversations… Relationships need to be upfront and honest… otherwise it’s just stupid to keep trying…
I’m reminded of the time that I found out B was still perusing match.com even though I sort of considered our ‘relationship’ (for lack of a better term) to be exclusive… I was hurt… he felt like I was checking up on him… but it was more than that… He was hiding it and I found it… Relationship Point #1: If you are hiding something, you shouldn’t be doing it… Period…
Issue #2 is the simple fact that he hasn’t told this woman about you after how many months? Why? My guess (and this is just me being my bitter self) is that he is hedging his bets… He may be skeptical that the relationship between you and him is going to last therefore he needs to keep her in the dugout, ready to go should you strike out… In my opinion, he just wants to eat his cake AND save it for later and it just doesn’t work that way…
Issue #3: You can honestly confront him any time you are ready to hear his excuses because that’s all you are going to get… At first, he will get angry because you invaded his privacy (see above regarding match.com and B). Then he may or may not feel regret and decide to either #1 - break it off with you for being a controlling bitch or #2 - tell her about you, explain that it’s over and done and to never email him again… My bet is on #3 - beg forgiveness and secretly continue emailing her but learn how to hide it better… Honestly? And I’m really sorry to say it… the damage is already done, isn’t it? You already don’t trust him… Even if he did choose option #2 (best case scenario), how long would it take for you to stop checking his email account to see if he’s still contacting her? Does he need to prove it to you for your curiosity to be satiated? In my book, the damage is already done…
Bottom line: By hiding the conversations from you, he’s lying to you… By hiding you from her, he’s lying to her… Both of you lose out… But really, HE’S the biggest loser for being an ass and keeping up the facade…
Just my opinion… take it for what it’s worth…